yellow a écrit :
alors, ma question est simple, pour vous ned kelly est il un bandit ou un robin des bois?
un de mes amis australien en a presque les larmes aux yeux quand il parle de lui, mais l'histoire du point de vue ou l'on se trouve change radicalement les choses....
Hmm, c'est difficile.
Peut etre, ca depend sur si on a vu le film ou pas!
Ou si on a visite "Kellyland" a Glenrowan (dans le nord de Victoria ou Ned est vecu) ou tout les choses concerne Ned Kelly.
Pour moi, I would say that during his life he was seen as nothing but a bandit, but the more time goes by (and the more money is made out of Tourism about him) the more like Robin des Bois he becomes!
But also as time goes by, more people are researching his life, reading the true accounts, and often discovering that perhaps, in the beginning, he wasn't so guilty, and it was injustice which made him angry and led to his life of crime. After reading one such book, I also feel quite a lot of sympathy for his early years.....but not the later ones.
on peut lire
http://www.walkabout.com.au/locations/V ... owan.shtml pour connaitre son histoire en bref
Hope this helps!
Kate